The bigger issue we face
- By CARDOMYTE
- Premium: Collision Course
- 81 Replies
I’ve voiced concerns for some time about BP. My biggest issue has always been his inability to build a “program”. He’s a great off coach, but he doesn’t focus enough time on all aspects of the game to be a “great” coach IMHO.
Our issues are trending in the wrong direction, and fast. We have major issues.
A quick example of 1 I’ll focus on is talent, and lackluster recruiting. Regardless of what your favorite recruiting website ranking says, with a BP class you have to look below the surface at the trends. Attrition has always been a challenge for his teams.
I’ve looked at classes since he’s been here the 2nd time. Here’s the B/D.
2014-25 signed
8 became starters at some point.
11 never showed, played, or transferred.
2015-24 signed (strongest)
17 started at some point
6 never showed, played, or transferred
2016-25
8 started
8 never showed, played, or transferred
2017-24
7 started
11 no show, not played, transferred. (Still time for those not played)
I’m taking out the 17 class, since we have a few RS and TBD on others. Looking at the other 3, you have 25 kids that never played in 3 years. This is where our depth issues are coming from. It’s essentially an entire class.
You can do the math and see that the middle ground of those between starting and not playing are kids that saw the field. Some are ST, some playing solid backup roles, a few are 2nd/3rd string.
I didn’t include, but we also had some JUCOs in there too. What that means is kids that didn’t play 4 years. Again, depth issues long term.
I also didn’t include any specifics where classes weren’t balanced in terms of position depth. Heavy on DB and WR certainly aren’t helping a lack of DL talent.
Today we’re playing, by my estimation, 10 TR FR. The new RS rule I guess is playing a part there, but I don’t think we’ll have the #’s to not keep playing them.
Bottom line, we’re not evaluating talent well enough, and we can see we’re certainly not coaching up those that stay well enough.
It’s getting worse.
Our issues are trending in the wrong direction, and fast. We have major issues.
A quick example of 1 I’ll focus on is talent, and lackluster recruiting. Regardless of what your favorite recruiting website ranking says, with a BP class you have to look below the surface at the trends. Attrition has always been a challenge for his teams.
I’ve looked at classes since he’s been here the 2nd time. Here’s the B/D.
2014-25 signed
8 became starters at some point.
11 never showed, played, or transferred.
2015-24 signed (strongest)
17 started at some point
6 never showed, played, or transferred
2016-25
8 started
8 never showed, played, or transferred
2017-24
7 started
11 no show, not played, transferred. (Still time for those not played)
I’m taking out the 17 class, since we have a few RS and TBD on others. Looking at the other 3, you have 25 kids that never played in 3 years. This is where our depth issues are coming from. It’s essentially an entire class.
You can do the math and see that the middle ground of those between starting and not playing are kids that saw the field. Some are ST, some playing solid backup roles, a few are 2nd/3rd string.
I didn’t include, but we also had some JUCOs in there too. What that means is kids that didn’t play 4 years. Again, depth issues long term.
I also didn’t include any specifics where classes weren’t balanced in terms of position depth. Heavy on DB and WR certainly aren’t helping a lack of DL talent.
Today we’re playing, by my estimation, 10 TR FR. The new RS rule I guess is playing a part there, but I don’t think we’ll have the #’s to not keep playing them.
Bottom line, we’re not evaluating talent well enough, and we can see we’re certainly not coaching up those that stay well enough.
It’s getting worse.