I never said they shouldn't count SF, I just think the results would be much different if the games were played now, as opposed to November/December.I see you don't want to tackle this, kyjeff, as you ignored the response from the other poster as well as mine. In your own words Uk's win over UNC shouldn't count or mean much at all because it was played in December, right? At the very least Uk's win "has an asterisk" as UNC was missing a key player, right? I can understand you trying to ignore your own words here because it severely lessens Uk's best win of the season and you don't want to look like hypocrite by applying your "rules" to other team's wins but not to your own.
I'm not sure what you want me to say, I'm not going to deny that a UK/UNC game played right now wouldn't yield different results, of course it would, both teams are much different now than they were back then.
But a Clemson v USC game, with Thornwell would have a much different result.
I still said that Clemson would probably win, on a neutral court against UGA and Bama, but that Clemson/UGA game would go down to the last possession.