My point is if Georgia, Alabama, LSU, Florida or Auburn are good/great being in the SEC isn’t the reason they are good. They are good/great because that year they had a really good/great team. That doesn’t mean the rest of the league was dominant. It doesn’t mean anything really. I would put that Louisville team, especially with Bush healthy, in the title game. Doesn’t mean the Big East was good or bad just Louisville had dudes.
That is why each P4 conference should get equal AQ in whatever the new playoff becomes. Settle it on the field.
I do see it like that, but I also understood their arguments a little more when Cincy made the playoff.
Cincy in 2021 was a great team and could compete with anyone. Forever they can beat their chest that they made the Final Four of the playoff and we didn't. They beat Notre Dame on the road that year and earned that spot. But I do get to thinking, could that 2016 Louisville team have easily won the 2021 AAC? Or what if Cincy had been in the Big Ten East that year and had Ohio State, Michigan, Michigan State, and Penn State on their schedule like Indiana had to deal with every season? Now they still would've been great, like an 8-4 season or 9-3 against a schedule like that means they are a really good team.
It's not that being in the SEC just makes you a great team. But I do see the point of that they have more of those teams capable of beating a really good team on any given week. Like WVU and Rutgers for us in 2006, the bottom type teams like Missouri, Kentucky, South Carolina, and Mississippi State are never title contenders. They would've never won our ACC division with Clemson/FSU, but you could say that on given years where they were 8-9 win teams in the SEC and could've won the ACC Coastal, old Big East, or AAC.
IT's not that all their teams are elite and could all win any conference on any given year, they usually only have 2-3 that are elite and could contend for a title like most top leagues, but their undercard of teams are a bit more talent. Doesn't mean a program like Vanderbilt wouldn't be the same as like Wake Forest or BC in the ACC, it just means that there isn't a week off.
I think where they get carried away, and mainly we only think of Kentucky fans(but they aren't real SEC football lol) but it's when a team like Florida is 6-6 or 7-5 and they go "FLOOORRRRRIDA WOULD BE UNDEFEATED IN THE ACC ITS NOT FAIR!!!" and no that's not true. Maybe they'd be slightly better not having as many tough games, but they would still drop a few games and not contend for the title.