Honestly, I'm always disappointed when the Cards don't make the NCAA Tournament- at least to some degree. I do understand circumstances, injuries, and other variables as well though. If this team wins around 20 games, maybe a couple upsets thrown in and looks competitive every night, but doesn't make the Tourney, I'd be disappointed but also would believe that Kelsey is on the right track.
The only way I'd be hugely disappointed is if he goes under .500 for some reason. I don't think he will though and until it looks otherwise, I believe he could make the NCAAT with this team. We'll see.