Recruiting Is not about what you want, but in the instance where CSS inherited the situation that Petrino left, it is more about signing what was available. JJ Weaver serves as an example, he was coveted out of Moore HS here in Louisville by both UK and UL. He had no intention of coming here, but it was not about Satterfield not recognizing his talent, or Scott not pursuing him right up until signing day ……. he just wanted to play in the SEC at UK, and that has been the case over these last 4 or 5 years now with so many of the head to head recruiting wars with UK.
Satterfield wanted a big NG for his 3-4 defense, and he was successful signing Jacques Turner out of So Miss. Unfortunately, the problem is that Turner is only 6’1” and 289 lbs; too small for this level of competition. I am sure Satterfield wanted someone bigger, but in truth ……. we got the best we could attract. Turner is good, he just cannot be expected to fight off offensive linemen (Darian Kinnarx) who are equally talented, but weigh 345 lbs. on a 6’5” frame.
Conversely, UK’s NT McCall is 6’3” and weighs 375 lbs. The size differential between UK and UL is not just these two examples …… it’s across the board. UK has emphasized large and talented OL-men, and have a tradition of attracting equally massive NTs.
Satterfield has not recruited well, but I am not sure anyone else could have done any better given the circumstances.