After the all systems failure of last season, Payne has a whole lot to prove in year 2. Given that disaster, I totally understand any skepticism regarding anything this staff does including recruiting in the offseason.
Payne has done nothing so far to be given the benefit of the doubt in any aspect of the job. Until he puts together a full and complete team and proves he can win a lot more games then he will continue to face doubt by the fanbase. The only thing he has shown so far is that he can have one of the worst seasons in D1 history.