ADVERTISEMENT

MLB suspensions

baseonballs

Two-Star Poster
Mar 7, 2007
1,233
16
26
I personally do not like A-Rod. With that being said, I am firmly convinced that A-rod's suspension is so much more than MLB protecting "the integrity of the game."

First of all, Bud Selig, the Commissioner of Baseball of MLB, makes a salary of $22 million this year and his estimated net worth is $400 million. He is the former team owner and team president of the Milwaukee Brewers. The New York Yankees do not have to pay any of A-Rod's salary while he is suspended. If A-Rod is out of the game through the 2014 season, the Yankees will save over $30 million of the contract that they agreed to (not that any player should be paid that much, but they agreed to it). If A-Rod is banned through the 2014 season when he is 40 years-old, I would bet that the Yankees would try to find a way to void A-Rod's contract through some clause. If A-Rod would be banned for life by MLB, the Yankees would not have to pay him - about $100 million. Selig actions save the Yankee's a lot of money and maybe a way out of a bad contract.

In addition, I believe MLB is trying to put closure on the "Steroid Era" with A-Rod's face as the image of the era. A-Rod is publicly not liked and could be targeted with less negative publicity for Major League Baseball. The Mitchell report concluded, though, that the MLB commissioners, club officials, the Players Association, and the players all share "to some extent in the responsibility for the steroid era." I am sure many players used steroids that never tested positive. Much of the use was before testing was mandatory. I have not heard Selig mention how MLB benefited during the this time, made money, and share in the responsibility. I would have to believe that MLB management knew (or did not want to know) about steroid use. Putting A-Rod's face to the Era does seems like a way a corporation is using a scapegoat. The process and all the parties involve do not seem to have taken their part of the responsibility.

A-Rod has never had a publicly reported positive test for PED's. How do we not know that other players are using companies like Biogenesis? Why not have a standard that would equally review players through testing? Improve testing and have a uniform standard. Otherwise, it sure seems to easy to believe that MLB has targeted certain players or at least has tried to find a scapegoat.

This post was edited on 8/5 9:21 PM by baseonballs
 
I know that this is a very minority opinion, but I think needs to be heard.

From the cited article below:

The aggressive pursuit of Rodriguez fits into baseball's recent patterns of demonizing unpopular players and casting them as the faces of the P.E.D. epidemic.

Fifteen years ago, baseball enjoyed its banquet years, with Mark McGwire and Sammy Sosa vying for the single-season home run record. Baseballs were flying out of stadiums, and turnstiles where whirling at a record pace.

Baseball life was lush.

We know now - and I suspect some baseball executives, managers and players knew then - that the chase was fueled by steroids. Major League Baseball and Selig in particular have made a show out of hunting down high-profile players. The process is selective.

McGwire, with Selig's blessing, was hired as the St. Louis Cardinals' hitting coach. Andy Pettitte, who admitted to using human growth hormone, pitches every fifth day for the Yankees.

A-Rod is baseball's latest villain. Not so long ago, he was being hailed as the knight who would save us from Barry Bonds.

Similarly, baseball, beginning with the commissioner, should want to know about these distribution networks. Instead, baseball puts on parades. The commissioner is fond of the dog-and-pony-show approach. Rather than working with players to identify manufacturing and distribution networks, baseball works with Biogenesis-like drug dealers to hunt down high-profile users and trots them out before a cheering public.


This post was edited on 8/6 7:31 AM by baseonballs

MLB Bullying Makes It Tempting to Root for A-Rod
 
COMMENTARY | He may not have the support from the New York Yankees organization or its fans, but Yankees third baseman Alex Rodriguez does have a case for arguing that Major League Baseball's 211-game suspension is extreme.

Ultimately, A-Rod's punishment may be measured against those handed down against Cabrera and Braun. Otherwise, he can rightly say that he's being singled out. Is it warranted? Perhaps, but the maligned slugger does have a case to have his suspension trimmed.


From: " Alex Rodriguez Has a Case for Arguing Suspension Is Unfair - Compared to Melky Cabrera's and Ryan Braun's Suspensions, A-Rod's Ban Seems Extreme"
Howard Z. Unger - Yahoo Sports

A-Rod Has Case That Suspension Unfair
 
MLB Comes Off Looking Bad in Firing Shyam Das, Arbitrator Who Overturned Ryan Braun's Suspension

Major League Baseball is taking its ball and going home. In what will undoubtedly be viewed as a case of sour grapes, the MLB has decided to fire Shyam Das, the arbitrator who overturned Ryan Braun's drug suspension in February.

Considering the MLB vehemently disagreed with the Braun decision at the time it was handed down, Das' firing comes off as petty. While the league is unlikely to admit it, it seems obvious that some ill will has been held toward Das in the wake of the Braun fiasco.

Das, whose vote was the decisive one in the Braun case, determined that there were inconsistencies in the collection and delivery process of one of Braun's urine samples, as it was not dropped off at a FedEx office the same day it was taken. Therefore, the case was tainted, and Das - who worked alongside Michael Weiner and Rob Manfred as part of a three-man panel - overturned the 50-game ban.

But instead of moving on and chalking the February decision up as a bold determination by an "independent" arbitrator, the MLB has decided to pull a typical 10-year-old schoolyard move. Things didn't go my way. OK, well I no longer want to play ? or in this case, you're fired.

Das has arbitrated cases for the MLB since 1999, and by all accounts appears to have been a well-respected employee. In fact, he also serves in such a capacity for the NFL, and he'll be hearing a grievance in the New Orleans Saints' Bountygate case on Wednesday.

The dismissal of an arbitrator is by no means shocking since, by terms of the Basic Agreement, either MLB management or the Players' Association can unilaterally dismiss the arbitrator at any time. It's just strange that after 13 years, Das is now being kicked to the curb, just months after a controversial decision that baseball officials were so strongly opposed to at the time.



This post was edited on 8/6 6:55 PM by baseonballs

MLB Comes Off Looking Bad in Firing Arbitrator
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT