I too believe that McGee was a juvenile who wanted to be a player with his homies. Relative to them--college kids--he had plenty of money. And he obviously doled it out one dollar at a time to get the skanks in this photo...
But McGee was an idiot thinking that was doing anything but making himself look worse. Fortunately, we're not very good at cheating. And the bottom line is it certainly didn't attract any recruits. You don't get penalized--not the full penalty anyway--for TRYING to do something wrong...anymore than you get electrocuted for trying to kill someone. That's where we fell on our swords--we chose electrocution.
And what might you conclude seeing these photos?...
I might question whether I had the right guy living in the dorm with the players. Yes, that WAS Pitino's mistake. If I saw this, how much more did Pitino see? I'd always thought that McGee was trying to be the guy he ended up being. Didn't take a rocket scientist, just someone with his eyes open.
BUT that's not the same as knowing about a violation and overlooking it. IMO that's the difference between giving Pitino a suspension or not.
I think all of this has been choreographed with the NCAA, and the penalties are over...