You don't care for Klenakis? Gee, I never made the connection!
Again, a lot of kids will go to Bama or tOSU etc if you or I recruited them. "Hey kid, we want you to come to Bama and win a NC. We do it pretty regularly you know". And the players have no clue who they do, or don't, want to play for until they're wherever they go.
Example: Bobby Petrino is known as an Offensive genius, and a QB developing machine. Arguably none better.
So, how many 5 star Offensive players do we sign every year? QB's? How many have we ever signed? If he can't do it here, why would we think some Asst Coach from somewhere else can magically bring in 4-5 star talent on a regular basis?
Oh, he has connections in HS's in the south you say?
So we get Coach Super Recruiter, he goes to those schools. Do the kids say "Hey we can't wait to follow you to Loueyville!!"? Or do they say (to themselves and peers) "I can't believe he left Bama!!"
So again, how do we recruit "better" when we are located in Louisville Ky, with very, very little home grown talent in our backyard?
I think our recruiting will start getting "better" 3 star, and the few 4's. We may even get a 5 once in a while. But we won't do it every year. We'll have to find the 4's that haven't been rated 4 yet. Just as we've always done.